I’d like to preface this post by saying that I know a lot of people here may not degree. Feel free to leave a comment – I post them all, as long as they’re respectful, even if you don’t agree with me!
Today, I read an article on CNN about now Nepal’s census this year would be recognizing a third gender. The LGBT community is celebrating on the streets of course, but I have to wonder this: Why?
Perhaps I have a limited view on the matter, since I’m not in the LGBT category, but as a sub, I certainly understand discrimination, especially as it pertains to sexuality. Let me explain to you how I see things, though.
I could be wrong, but every census-like form I’ve ever filled out asked for sex, not gender. To me, sex is what is between your legs, what your DNA says, apart from how you feel in the inside. If you’re pre-op, perhaps there’s an argument for marking female when you still have a penis or male when you still have a vagina, but again, to me, sex is all about whether you pee sitting down or standing up. In fact, that’s one of the main arguments for filling out the form correctly – they sometimes help determine things like how many public bathrooms to install. You are born physically male or physically female. That’s not discrimination. That’s fact.*
Gender, in my opinion, is how you feel on the inside. Some of us are lucky enough to lead lives where we feel like the inside matches the outside. I say “lucky” not because there’s something wrong with you if you don’t, but only because it must be incredibly hard to deal with your feelings, especially as a child, if your inside and outside doesn’t match given today’s culture around the world, not just in Nepal. I’ve seen friends struggle with it, and I don’t wish that on anyone.
When it comes to sexuality, I think you can be attracted to both sex and gender, and the two might not match up. I personally am attracted to someone who is physically male. What can I say, I like a nice cock. I’m also attracted to someone who’s stereotypically male in terms of inward feelings – I like dating guys who are rugged, dominant, etc. I’ve met females who have these characteristics, and while that does slightly attract me, the no penis thing is a deal breaker. Likewise, I’ve met males who have the penis, but are submissive, and while I might be attracted physically, I have no connection mentally. For me, it takes both things. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with being attracted to a specific sex or a specific gender. You might like submissive, straight men or butch lesbians or people with blue eyes or people with nice feet or whatever. Attraction is attraction – you can’t change your gut (or rather, below-the-belt) reaction to other people.
Anyway, this brings me back to my original question – why? What is the need for a third gender category? Because really, I don’t feel like the government (or anyone controlling a census) needs to know how you feel on the inside. Your sex, the actual dangly or not-so-dangly parts between your legs…that might make sense to know so they can provide the right services (like public bathrooms or OBGYN services) in the right amounts in every community, but beyond that, why is the relevant? Be who you want to be. Some kind of third gender just seems like a category made to appease people who are vocal for gay rights, even though it doesn’t actually do anything for gay rights.
Instead of some kind of silly third gender, I’d like to see the whole gender/sex thing gone altogether. If they need to collect data to ensure they provide the right services, they can flat-out ask that (for example, “Do you use OBGYN services in your community?”). Otherwise, it shouldn’t matter. We’re just creating more difficult-to-understand labels for ourselves.
So that’s my opinion. I don’t get it, I don’t like it, and I don’t apologize for that. I think there are a lot of cool things going on right now in the LGBT community for gay rights. This is not one of them.
*Yes, a very small percentage are not born male or female (physically), but this is a rare medical condition that occurs when you have a genetic problem. If anything, I could support that as a third gender before the category as it stands now.
Related Articles:
- If You’re not a Man and not a Woman, Perhaps you are Nepalese (queerty.com)
- “Parents keep child’s gender under wraps (methodius.blogspot.com)
- The straightjacket of gender (aworldoflies.wordpress.com)










